Chapter I
Judge Smith, a highly esteemed citizen of Plunkville, is found murdered in his bed at his home. He has been stabbed with a pair of , poisoned with “rough on rats.” His throat has been cut with an handled razor, an in his arm has been opened, and he has been shot full of buckshot from a double-barreled gun.
The is summoned and the room examined. On the ceiling is a bloody footprint, and on the floor are found a lady’s , with the initials “J. B.,” a package of cigarettes and a ham sandwich. The coroner renders a of suicide.